Dogs | Toys

Best Long-Lasting Dog Chews for Aggressive Chewers in Australia

Some dogs get through a new toy in an afternoon. For a dog like that, a long-lasting edible chew gives it something tough to chew that it can also eat. The thing to watch is hardness, because chewing very hard objects is a common cause of broken teeth. A chew you can’t dent with your fingernail is too hard, and we explain that test below. We’ve compared four single-ingredient chews made from tendon, pizzle and beef skin. They range from a bulk bag of Aussie beef tendon to a kangaroo option for dogs that need a break from beef.

Best for Indoor Chewing

Natural Farm Beef Collagen Sticks 30 cm, 5 Pack
3.9

Natural Farm Beef Collagen Sticks 30 cm, 5 Pack

  • Odour-free beef skin chew
  • For medium and heavy chewers

  • Beef sourced from Brazil

An edible chew is food, so your dog will eat it in the end. A good one keeps a strong chewer busy, wears down slowly and tells you exactly what’s in it. A poor one is too hard, too small or full of extras. These are the five points we weigh up when we compare chews for a dog that bites hard.

What to look for in a long-lasting dog chew

Five things we’d check before buying — scroll across to read them all.

Hardness

Most vet dentists use a thumbnail test: you should be able to dent a chew with your fingernail, Cornell’s canine health centre explains. It also lists antlers, hooves and bones as chews to avoid.

Size

Pick a chew sized for your dog. Larger chews are harder, so the biggest one on offer isn’t always the right choice for a small dog.

Ingredients

A single-ingredient chew tells you exactly which protein your dog is eating. That matters most for dogs that don’t do well on one meat, such as beef.

Calories

A long chew is still food, and a dried meat chew can carry a lot of calories. Count it as part of the day’s food, and trim meals a little on chew days.

Supervision

Every chew in this guide is made to be eaten with you nearby. Take it away once it’s small enough to swallow whole, and wash your hands after handling it.

At a glance

Our four chews for heavy chewers compared, with our one-line take on each.

RankProductBest forKey featurePrice guideCheck price link
Best Bully Stick Pick
Murgon Munchies Aussie Beef Bully Sticks 100g
Murgon Munchies Aussie Beef Bully Sticks 100g
Owners who want a classic bully stickHand-trimmed Aussie beef pizzle from Queensland$ (100 g)Check price
Best Non-Beef Protein
Kazoo Prime Cuts Aussie Kangaroo Tendons 250g
Kazoo Prime Cuts Aussie Kangaroo Tendons 250g
Dogs that need a break from beefAustralian kangaroo tendon, no additives$$ (250 g)Check price
Best for Indoor Chewing
Natural Farm Beef Collagen Sticks 30 cm, 5 Pack
Natural Farm Beef Collagen Sticks 30 cm, 5 Pack
Dogs that chew inside, where smell mattersOdour-free sticks made from beef skin$$Check price

Our picks in detail

What we like, what to watch, and which dog each chew suits.

Best Bully Stick Pick: Murgon Munchies Aussie Beef Bully Sticks 100g

Bottom line — a single-ingredient Queensland bully stick that’s easy to trust, in a small bag that suits a first try.

Murgon Munchies are small-batch treats made in Murgon, in Queensland’s South Burnett. These bully sticks are beef pizzle and nothing else, from 100% Australian beef. They’re hand-trimmed and air dried, typically at 50 to 70°C for 20 to 48 hours. The plant is HACCP accredited, which is a food-safety standard.

A bully stick is the classic long chew. It’s a stick shape a dog can hold between its paws and work at from one end. The pack carries a chew meter to help you match it to your dog. The 100 g bag is small for a heavy chewer, so we’d treat it as a way to see how your dog handles pizzle before you buy more. That small bag is also why it scores below our top pick. Calories vary a lot from one bully stick to the next, so trim dinner a little on a chew night. Wash your hands after handling them.

What we loveAreas for improvement
  • 100% Australian beef, made in Murgon
  • Hand-trimmed and slowly air dried
  • Made in a HACCP-accredited facility
  • Small bag for a big chewer
  • Beef, so not for beef-sensitive dogs
  • Calories add up on a long stick

Best Non-Beef Protein: Kazoo Prime Cuts Aussie Kangaroo Tendons 250g

Bottom line — tough Australian kangaroo tendon for the dog that can’t have beef, at a price that makes it a special-purpose chew.

Kangaroo is the obvious Aussie choice for a dog that doesn’t do well on beef. This 250 g bag holds Australian-made kangaroo tendon with no additives or preservatives. It scores 4 on Kazoo’s JAWS toughness scale, the same as the beef tendon. As with the beef, that score only tells you how tough the chew is to get through.

It costs the most of the four for a bag half the size of our top pick. We’d only buy it for dogs that need a protein other than beef. If your dog has a diagnosed food allergy, check with your vet before you change proteins. Bring it in slowly, the way you would any new treat. Like the beef version, it’s a chew to hand over while you’re home. Dent-test the first piece, and take the last small piece away before it can be swallowed whole.

What we loveAreas for improvement
  • Kangaroo protein for dogs off beef
  • Australian-made, no additives or preservatives
  • Tendon chew, like our top pick
  • Dearest pick here at today’s prices
  • Half the bag size of the beef tendon
  • A new protein needs a slow start

Best for Indoor Chewing: Natural Farm Beef Collagen Sticks 30 cm, 5 Pack

Bottom line — the chew to pick when your dog chews on the lounge-room rug and a smelly stick isn’t an option.

Dried meat chews can have a strong smell. That matters if your dog does its chewing on the lounge-room rug. These sticks are 30 cm long and come five to a pack. They’re made from one ingredient, natural beef skin, and they’re odour-free. They’re made for medium and heavy chewers, and they’re 95% collagen.

Start slowly with this one. Give three to five minutes of chewing at first, and build up over five days. The beef comes from grass-fed, free-range cattle in Brazil. That puts it behind the three Australian-made picks for us, and it’s a big part of the lower score. It’s also beef, so it won’t help a dog that needs a different protein. For a dog that chews indoors while you work from home, though, a chew without the smell is worth a lot. Stay close while it chews, as with every pick here.

What we loveAreas for improvement
  • Odour-free, so it suits indoor chewing
  • Single ingredient: natural beef skin
  • Made for medium and heavy chewers
  • Made with Brazilian beef
  • Needs a slow start over five days
  • Beef, so not for beef-sensitive dogs

FAQ

Are bully sticks safe for a dog that chews hard?
Bully sticks are dried beef pizzle, a single-ingredient chew. Give each new bag the thumbnail test, pick a stick that suits your dog’s size, and take the last short piece away so it can’t be swallowed whole. Stay nearby while your dog chews. Every chew in this guide is meant to be eaten under supervision, and that includes bully sticks.
How long should a long-lasting dog chew last?
There’s no fixed answer, because it depends on the dog and how hard it chews. A chew that keeps one dog busy for days might be gone in a single sitting with another. Keep each session short, and put the rest away for next time.
Are antlers or bones a better choice for an aggressive chewer?
No. Antlers, hooves and bones are on the list of chews vets suggest avoiding, because they can break a tooth or splinter and cause stomach problems. Give any very hard chew the thumbnail test before your dog gets it: if your fingernail can’t dent it, it’s too hard for a dog that bites down hard.
Is kangaroo a good chew for a dog with a beef allergy?
Kangaroo is a different protein from beef, so it’s an option for dogs that don’t do well on beef. If your dog has a diagnosed food allergy, talk to your vet first, because the right protein depends on what your dog reacts to. Our guide to dog allergies in Australia covers the signs to look for. Whatever protein you choose, bring any new chew in slowly and watch for an upset tummy afterwards.
Do I need to wash my hands after handling bully sticks?
Yes, it’s a good habit. A 2013 study of 26 bully sticks found C. difficile in one, MRSA in one and an antibiotic-resistant E. coli in one, and the authors advise handwashing after contact with treats. The same study found calories varied more than twofold from one stick to the next, so count a big chew as part of the day’s food.

Final thoughts

The best chew for a heavy chewer lasts a long time without being hard enough to break a tooth. I have a staffy called Pepper, so safe chews for strong jaws are something I think about often. I’d pick a chew that dents under my fingernail, because very hard chews are a common cause of broken teeth.

My advice is simple. Buy single-ingredient, pick a size that suits your dog, stay in the room, and take the last bit away. Give your dog tough rubber toys as well, and our guide to toys for aggressive chewers covers those. And count the chews as food. A long chew most nights adds calories, so give slightly smaller meals to keep your dog at a healthy weight.

We Think You’ll Also Like These Guides